Article Keyword: motivated reasoning

What is Often Overlooked May Prove to Be Invaluable – Herlina, S. Manap – Is. 36

What is Often Overlooked May Prove to Be Invaluable

by Herlina, S. Manap (Indonesia)

Abstract: This article examines the problem of premature epistemic closure in contemporary knowledge production, particularly the tendency to dismiss uncertain or controversial claims before adequate testing has occurred. It argues that responsible inquiry requires methodological rigour without collapsing into either uncritical belief or premature rejection. Drawing on fallibilism, falsifiability, motivated reasoning, and critical hermeneutics, the article proposes that knowledge should be evaluated through degrees of justification rather than rigid binaries of truth and error. It further argues that double standards often emerge when disfavoured claims are subjected to unusually strict evidential demands while preferred beliefs or authoritative texts escape comparable scrutiny. Using research on Cases of

… Read the rest